Skip to article
Series
Finance
Article series · Finance

Continue this series

Part 5
  1. ForewordIntroducing the EXA Finance Series
  2. Part 1FI EP01 | Who Should Get the Bonus?
  3. Part 2FI EP02 | 3+1 Measures of Business Performance: Which Reflects the Truth?
  4. Part 3FI EP03 | A Business Is a Cash-Generating Machine
  5. Part 4FI EP04 | We Ask Again: Who Should Get the Bonus?
  6. Part 5FI EP05 | Is the Company's Ability to Generate Cash Under Threat?
Part 5

FI EP05 | Is the Company's Ability to Generate Cash Under Threat?

Assessing cash-generating capacity through the amount and trend of throughput and how much operating expense it covers

Article overview

The operating question behind this article

Which figures tell us whether the company's ability to generate cash is under threat?

What the article argues

Assess cash-generating capacity by considering the amount of throughput, how much operating expense it covers, and its trend. When operating expense changes little, a sustained decline in throughput narrows the margin available to cover it and threatens the company's cash-generating capacity.

1. Cash Flow from Operating Activities

Tuesday, 8 a.m. The finance office.

The finance manager opened his notebook. The question the professor had asked at the end of last week's class was written at the bottom of the page.

'If net income cannot tell us how much money a company earned, what figure should we use to judge its ability to make money?'

He had spent the week working out his answer. It was operating cash flow.

His reasoning was clear. Net income changes with costing methods and valuations. In last week's class, the same company had arrived at three net income figures for the same period. Operating cash flow worked differently. It reflected the cash that actually came in and went out. At every monthly close, he started with net income for the period, adjusted for changes in inventories, receivables, and payables, and arrived at operating cash flow. That was how the indirect method worked in the statement of cash flows. The figure was the same whichever costing method he chose.

He wrote three lines in his notebook.

'Operating cash flow. Cash basis. Independent of judgments about valuation and costing.'

He paused, pen in hand. Operating cash flow had risen sharply last month from the month before. Two major customers had paid at the same time. The month before, a cluster of outgoing payments had pushed the figure sharply down. The company's operations had changed little between the two months. He could explain exactly why the figure had swung. He was less sure that he could call it a change in the company's ability to make money, its cash-generating capacity.

He put a question mark beneath the three lines. The tenth class was at 2 p.m.


2. Money the Company Brings In from Outside

The professor copied last week's question onto the board.

"We'll start with this question today. What figure do you use to judge a company's ability to make money?"

"Sales revenue," the sales executive answered first. "Without sales, nothing gets started."

"Operating profit," said the head of a small company. "There's little point in increasing sales if costs rise even more."

The cost accountant offered gross profit. It was the figure he looked at every month.

The finance manager answered last.

"Operating cash flow. Last week we saw that net income varies with the way you calculate it. Operating cash flow reflects cash actually coming in and going out. A change in costing method doesn't change it."

The professor wrote the four answers side by side on the board and underlined the last one.

"Your answer follows directly from last week's discussion. Operating cash flow reflects actual cash, independent of the costing method. It's an important figure. Let me ask you this. How much does it move from month to month?"

The finance manager thought for a moment. He remembered the question mark he had written that morning.

"Quite a bit. It rose sharply last month when payments from major customers came in together. The month before, it fell sharply because our payments came due together. Our operations were much the same in both months."

"Exactly. Operating cash flow shows the cash actually realized during the period. It changes from one period to the next depending on when payments are collected and made, and on how much inventories and receivables rise or fall. That information is essential for managing cash. Today's question is a little different. We're asking how much money the company generates from outside over its operating cycle. We are looking beyond cash realized in a particular month or at the particular point in time we discussed earlier. Our concern is the company's ability to generate cash through its current operating cycle, rather than the distant past or future. The two questions call for different figures."

The professor wrote an equation in the center of the board.

Throughput=Sales revenue−Material costs\text{Throughput} = \text{Sales revenue} - \text{Material costs}

"You've seen this figure before, when we worked through Throughput Accounting in the seventh class. We looked at it then as a costing method. Today we'll look at what the same figure means in finance. Sales revenue is the money customers pay the company. The part that covers material costs is money generated by suppliers. The company pays that share to them. Throughput, the amount left after subtracting material costs from sales revenue, is the total money the company brings in from outside."

The professor wrote another line beneath the equation.

Throughput: How much cash has the company generated from outside?

"Salaries, electricity, rent, interest, capital expenditure, dividends. The company has to cover all of these with the throughput it generates from outside. Money that comes in outside throughput, through borrowing, issuing equity, or selling assets, for example, is money the core business did not generate."

The professor pointed to the equation again.

"There's a condition we have to check. Sales revenue and material costs are recognized on an accrual basis. Those amounts include items for which cash has yet to change hands."

The cost accountant raised his hand.

"That's what I pointed out last time. A substantial part of sales revenue is still in accounts receivable, and some of the material costs are still in accounts payable. Until the money comes back, it isn't cash. Can we call that figure 'money the company has brought in'?"

"We have to answer that question for the definition to hold," the professor said. "Let me start with your company. When do you receive payment for a sale?"

"We sell directly to consumers. Most pay by card, so the money comes in within a few days."

"And your company?" he asked the finance manager.

"We sell to businesses. We run credit checks before taking on customers, and most of them are customers we've dealt with for a long time. We collect within two or three months, depending on the payment terms. Some receivables do go uncollected, but they account for a very small share of sales. We provide for them separately through an allowance for doubtful accounts."

The professor nodded. He wrote his questions on the board one by one and began to make his case.

"First, sales revenue is eventually collected in full in cash. Some receivables may be written off. As our finance manager says, though, they are a tiny share of sales, and in materiality terms they do not change the decision. No company sells goods intending to go unpaid. Do you agree?"

Several people nodded.

"Second, the materials the company buys are likewise paid for in full in cash. It would be unrealistic to assume the company buys materials intending to cheat its suppliers out of payment. Do you agree with that as well?"

"Of course," said the company head. "No one would supply materials to a company like that."

The professor drew two arrows on the board, one from the customer to the company and the other from the company to the supplier.

"Third, timing. The cycle for selling goods and buying materials is fairly short. What would happen if you bought materials and told your supplier you would pay six months or a year later?"

"You couldn't buy the next lot of materials," the cost accountant replied. "The supplier would stop doing business with you. The supplier needs to be paid to buy more materials and pay its staff. No supplier will keep delivering without getting paid."

"Exactly. The company couldn't stay in business. The same goes for the other side. Would any company sell products expecting to collect payment six months or a year later?"

"No," said the finance manager. "In the meantime it couldn't pay wages or buy materials. It wouldn't survive."

"That's right. A company that regards those terms as normal and accepts them cannot stay in business. It's common sense, and the logic holds."

The professor drew a line beneath the three questions.

"So sales and purchases both turn into cash, and they do so in a short time. Viewed over the operating cycle, we can therefore treat both as cash without introducing an error into our decisions. If sales revenue and material costs are cash, then throughput, the difference between them, is also entirely cash from the standpoint of the operating cycle. Does that follow?"

No one in the room objected.

The cost accountant looked down at his notes.

"That's different from Company B's inventory last time. Those 900 units hadn't sold, so there was no basis for expecting collection. Here we count only what's already been sold."

"Exactly. The sales that go into throughput are completed sales for which payment is now due. The proceeds soon come back as cash within the operating cycle."

The professor pointed to the equations on the board in turn.

"Let's put it together. Throughput is cash. Throughput is all the money the company has brought in from outside. And throughput is the surplus left after deducting from sales the material costs paid to suppliers. If all three are true, what follows?"

The finance manager answered, looking at the board.

"Then throughput is the Cash Value Added the company has generated. It's the cash the company itself has produced after taking out the suppliers' share."

"Exactly. By the definition of value added, we can conclude that throughput is Cash Value Added."

The professor wrote a final line beneath the equation.

Throughput=Cash Value Added\text{Throughput} = \text{Cash Value Added}

The finance manager wrote two lines next to the question mark in his notebook.

'Operating cash flow: the difference between cash inflows and cash outflows from operating activities during the period.'

'Throughput: cash the company generates from outside over the operating cycle.'

He didn't erase the first line. The two figures answered different questions.


3. Operating Expense and Cash Net Income

"If throughput is the money coming in, next come the costs that money has to cover." The professor cleared the left side of the board. "Before that, let me check one thing. Last week, what did you say was your reason for starting your company?"

"To make money."

"How do you make it?"

The company head smiled briefly. "By selling products. I didn't start the company to earn interest on deposits or sell buildings."

"That's your core business. Making money by selling products. Financial transactions and the disposal of fixed assets are outside that business. The operating cycle we drew in the eighth class is the cycle of your core business. You use cash to buy materials, manufacture products, sell them, and collect the proceeds in cash. Today we're discussing the routine decisions that recur within that cycle."

The professor looked at the cost accountant.

"Would you sort the expenses on the company's income statement from that perspective? Leave out material costs, which we've already deducted from throughput. The criterion is whether the expense is incurred to carry out or support the operating cycle."

The cost accountant went to the board and started listing accounts on the left. Salaries, employee benefits, advertising, electricity, service fees, rent. On the right he listed inventory valuation losses and foreign currency translation losses. His chalk stopped at depreciation.

"The expenses on the left arise each month and are paid each month. They are paid in cash, or will be soon. The expenses on the right arise from valuations. The timing and amounts recorded in profit or loss differ from the actual cash flows. Depreciation is harder to place. We recognize it every month, but no cash goes out for it that month."

"You're quite right that depreciation isn't a cash payment that month. The payment made when you buy the equipment is an investing cash flow. The factory, its equipment, and the head office building are the assets that make the operating cycle possible and support it. The operating cycle also has to cover the cost of using those assets. Depreciation allocates the depreciable portion of an asset's acquisition cost over its useful life." The professor moved depreciation to the left-hand column. "We'll call the left-hand column Operating Expense. These are the costs of carrying out and supporting the operating cycle. They include costs paid in cash, like salaries or rent, and expenses like depreciation that do not require cash in the period. Today we'll look at how much of that operating expense throughput covers."

The professor wrote a new equation beside the throughput equation.

Throughput−Operating Expense=Cash Net Income\text{Throughput} - \text{Operating Expense} = \text{Cash Net Income}

"Accounting net income reflects operating expense, costs arising from valuations, and amounts that vary with the costing method. Net income serves a purpose of its own. Today's question calls for a different figure. How much money comes into the company, and what does it cover? Subtracting operating expense from throughput shows how much room is left after the operating cycle has covered its operating expense. For convenience in this class, we'll call that cash net income. It isn't an official term. It differs from the increase in the bank balance over a quarter because collections and payments take time, and because operating expense includes items such as depreciation that differ from the period's cash outlays. Over repeated cycles, however, the larger the cash net income, the more money the company has made."

The professor looked around the room.

"Does operating expense at your companies move as much as sales do?"

"No," the company head answered first. "Even in months when sales are down, we pay the same salaries and rent."

Several people nodded.

"That's true of most companies. Operating expense does change, but within a relatively narrow range. Most of it is what the company has to spend to keep operating. There are exceptions, of course. An unusual event, such as a large loss on a foreign exchange derivative contract, can threaten a company's survival. Those risks matter a great deal and call for a separate framework. Today we're discussing decisions made within the cycle of the core business. They are among the company's most important and most frequently repeated decisions. We want to see the company's cash-generating capacity, the underlying condition of its operating cycle, with exceptional events set aside. When operating expense is largely fixed in this way, judge that capacity by how much of the operating expense the company can cover with the throughput it generates."

The company head raised his hand.

"Does cash net income tell us how much money we made, then? We bought a piece of equipment last year. We paid for it all at once last year, but here it goes into the calculation as depreciation spread across years."

"That's right. Cash net income and the money earned are different. Depreciation is a cost allocated over the period the equipment is used. The equipment payment is an investment paid when the company acquires it. The difference between cash net income and money earned comes from money the company invests internally. Money put into equipment and inventory. There is no guarantee that the company will recover all that money in cash or that it will generate new cash. Strictly speaking, it isn't fully the company's money yet. Even so, the company has to invest it. It is an uncertain but unavoidable investment if the business is to continue. Next class we'll look at how to judge that investment. Today we'll focus on the step before it, how much operating expense throughput can cover."

The professor pointed to both equations in turn.

"If the operating expense to be covered by throughput changes little, the size of cash net income is determined by throughput. When throughput trends downward, the margin available to cover operating expense shrinks as well. Let's look at the amount and trend of throughput using actual figures."


4. Six Quarters at One Company

The professor brought up a table on the screen.

"This is a real case. I won't name the company. The table shows sales revenue and material costs for six consecutive quarters."

Year 1 Q1Year 1 Q2Year 1 Q3Year 1 Q4Year 2 Q1Year 2 Q2
Sales revenue172,616151,320126,438119,046117,846122,107
Material costs36,28228,69923,90423,50722,73023,325

"Would you calculate throughput?"

The finance manager came up to the board, subtracted material costs from sales revenue, and filled in the third row.

Year 1 Q1Year 1 Q2Year 1 Q3Year 1 Q4Year 2 Q1Year 2 Q2
Throughput136,334122,621102,53495,53995,11698,782

"Let's also look at throughput as a share of sales revenue."

The finance manager divided throughput by sales revenue for each quarter. It was 78.98% in the first quarter and 80.90% in the last. It was around 80% in each of the four quarters in between.

"The ratio actually improved," he said. "Material costs took up a smaller share of sales revenue."

"That's right. Each unit of sales revenue brought more money into the company," the professor said.

The cost accountant looked back at the table. "If material costs fell as a share of sales, does that mean purchasing did a good job?"

"The ratio alone doesn't tell us. What we deduct in calculating throughput is directly variable costs, such as material costs, as we defined them in the seventh class. We don't deduct amounts allocated by a costing system. Purchases of raw and subsidiary materials used in the products sold are the main example. The deduction also includes costs such as what the company actually paid for outsourced processing on those products and utility costs that vary directly with production volume. It does not include labor costs or overhead. The share is a percentage of sales revenue, so it can change when selling prices change. On the material cost side, there are two ways it can move. One is the product. A design change that alters the bill of materials, or a shift in the mix of products sold, will change material costs. The other is purchase prices. Those can change even when the bill of materials stays the same.

"Prices for raw and subsidiary materials are closely tied to the broader economy. A rise in copper prices puts upward pressure on the prices of materials containing copper. An increase in oil prices also affects what it costs to buy petroleum-based materials. When exchange rates move, the amount the company pays in its own currency for imported materials changes. If a war disrupts the supply or transport of raw materials, purchasing costs can rise as well. Suppliers' pricing policies and the company's sourcing capabilities also matter. Purchasing costs can rise even when selling prices stay the same."

"Then how do you tell those causes apart?"

"You have to track purchasing costs separately. Commodity price indices and international market prices for copper and crude oil can tell you where prices are moving outside the company. Companies buy different mixes of materials and have different contract terms, though, so you have to check how much of that movement shows up in actual purchasing costs. This company's decision-making system had a purchase price index. It set the base-year purchase price for each item at 100 and showed how prices moved for the key materials that accounted for most material costs. In a period outside the one shown here, the index rose from 100 to 120. That's why the company needs to keep a close watch on the broader economy." The professor turned back to the table. "Compare the first and last quarters here. Material costs fell as a share of sales, and the throughput ratio rose by that much. Now shall we look at the amount?"

The finance manager read the third row from left to right. From 136,334 to 98,782. Throughput had fallen 27.5% over the six quarters. While the ratio improved, the amount fell overall.

The sales executive raised his hand.

"Couldn't we reach the same conclusion from sales alone in this table? Sales fell by 29%. I don't quite see why we have to calculate throughput separately."

"That's a fair objection," said the professor. "Sales and throughput moved in the same direction in this case. Throughput didn't warn us about the trouble any earlier than sales. But calculating throughput brings something else to light. The throughput ratio rose from 78.98% to 80.90%, an increase of 1.92 percentage points. Despite that improvement, the amount of throughput fell by 27.5%. The drop in sales overwhelmed the gain. The fall in sales is what pulled this company's throughput down. Sales alone don't let us isolate the cause that way. And what covers salaries, rent, and interest is the amount of throughput, not the ratio. Operating expense is an amount of money. If you want to work with ratios, express operating expense as a share of sales too. If operating expense fails to fall in the same proportion as sales, its share of sales rises as sales decline."

"But it did go up in the last quarter," the sales executive said. "From 95,116 to 98,782. In sales we'd take that as a sign of recovery."

"Up 3.9%." The professor plotted the six quarters of throughput on the board and drew a trend line. "The line that best fits all six points has a slope of −7,922 per quarter. Comparing just the first and last quarters gives an average decline of 7,510 per quarter. The last-quarter rebound and the downward trend over all six quarters are both real. We can't use this line to predict next quarter's figure. The figures to come will tell us whether the rebound marks a change in direction."

The professor touched the end of the line with his chalk.

"But the question becomes clear. Let's say most of the operating expense throughput has to cover is fixed and changes little. If throughput trends downward in those conditions, the gap between throughput and operating expense, the margin we call cash net income, narrows as long as the decline continues. If throughput stabilizes above operating expense, the company still makes money. If the company cannot reverse the trend and throughput keeps falling until it no longer covers operating expense, the company will begin losing money in its operating cycle. There is a limit to cutting operating expense. It comes from the nature of those expenses. That leads to an unavoidable conclusion."

"If you can't reverse the decline in throughput, you'll lose that money even if you do everything you can. There is no getting around it."

The room fell quiet. The production manager raised his hand.

"Couldn't we cut costs further? Our factory has a cost reduction target every year."

"Cutting costs is necessary. But as we saw, most operating expense is basic spending that keeps the company running. There is a limit to how far you can keep cutting it. You can't offset declining throughput indefinitely by cutting operating expense."

"Then it's clear what this company needs to do. Material costs already account for a smaller share of sales, and there is a limit to cutting operating expense. If the fall in sales is what pulled throughput down, increasing sales has to be a company-wide effort. It needs sales that raise throughput. Lowering prices to lift sales revenue alone won't do that."

"The economy was probably slowing at the time," said the sales executive. "If the market was weak, there was only so much the sales team could do."

"That may be. But if you put the decline in sales entirely down to the market, all the company can do is wait for the economy to recover." The professor looked at the finance manager. "We're looking at typical manufacturers with an established base of customers they have served for years. Like your company, they take on new customers carefully after checking their credit. When sales are falling at a company with an established customer base, the first place to look is inside the company.

"Even when it looks as if the market is holding sales back, the root cause usually lies in company policies rather than a lack of customers. Instead of asking where to find new customers, ask why existing customers have reduced their orders, why they are moving orders to another supplier, or why they are holding back additional orders. To increase sales, the company has to examine and improve the policies behind those reasons.

"If the company builds that capability, it can give existing customers a reason to place more orders, and its reputation can spread through industry networks." The professor looked from the production manager to the plant manager. "Customers care about the delivery dates and quality they were promised. When those become unreliable, customers' opinion of the company suffers first. Orders fall afterward. So we need to ask whether the plant builds a production schedule that lets it keep its promises to customers, and whether production actually follows that schedule. If each operation is evaluated on keeping its equipment busy ahead of meeting delivery dates, people on the floor may release work to boost their own operation's performance at the expense of the overall plan. Work in process can then pile up while the products customers are waiting for take longer to finish. We need to review whether performance is judged by the flow of the whole plant and by customer delivery dates rather than by individual operations' results, and whether those criteria govern work release and schedule changes. That is what it means to put internal policies right. We go into production scheduling, buffers, and operating with finite production capacity in depth in the Manufacturing Operations course. When the plant can reliably deliver on time and meet quality requirements, the sales team can use that capability to compete for orders. That reliability is the weapon the plant gives sales."

The professor went back to the first question on the board.

"If you ask why throughput, I'd answer by going back to the goal. If the company's goal is to make money, we have to look where the money comes in. If you lose your car keys in the dark, you can't expect to find them under a bright streetlight just because it's easier to see there."

"This company knew its sales were falling too. Yet it had never calculated or reviewed throughput in its decision-making. Put this table next to operating expense and you can ask one question about both how much of its operating expense the money coming in covers and where that margin is headed. Let's ask it now, from the perspective of the operating cycle. Is this company's ability to generate cash under threat? Will it start losing money?"

The finance manager answered, looking at the line on the board.

"Its ability to generate cash is under threat. If the last-quarter rebound doesn't change the trend and throughput keeps falling until it can no longer cover operating expense, the company will lose money."

"If that's the answer, the company's cash-generating capacity is under threat whatever the other figures may say. The ratio improved, and there was a rebound in the last quarter. Both are facts. Even so, if each tells us only part of what's going on, it's a half-truth. Base the judgment on the logic inherent in the situation, rather than the authority of a textbook or industry custom."

The professor put down the chalk.

"One final point. If we stop once we've recognized the answer, we've made an observation and left the decision unmade. Once you have an answer, ask, 'So what are we going to do?' and move on to the next question. Decision-making is a chain of reasoning in which each answer leads to the next question."


5. The Next Question

After class the finance manager stayed in his seat to organize his notes. On one page were the three lines and question mark he'd written in the morning, and the two lines he'd written during class.

The plant manager walked over and looked at the notebook.

"Are you dropping operating cash flow?"

"No. I'll keep looking at it. I need to know every day how much cash is coming in and going out this month," the finance manager said. "But when we ask how well the company can make money, we need to put other figures alongside it."

The plant manager nodded.

The finance manager turned to a fresh page. At the top he copied the professor's last words.

'Stop at recognizing the answer and all you have is an observation. So what are we going to do?'

Underneath he wrote down what to do when he returned to the company. There were no new figures to produce. Sales revenue, material costs, and operating expense were all figures the company closed each month. He only had to put them in a different arrangement to answer today's question.

'Calculate throughput for the last six quarters and put it next to operating expense. Put operating cash flow beside them.'

'In which direction is throughput moving? How large is the gap between throughput and operating expense?'

'If throughput moved, what caused it? Sales volume, selling prices, product mix, or material costs?'

'If it was material costs, was it the bill of materials or purchase prices? Which way is the purchase price index moving?'

'If it was sales, are our policies and the way we handle delivery and quality keeping established customers from ordering under current market conditions? What weapon can the plant give sales?'

'Which of these can the company change next quarter, and what constraints limit the choice?'

Next to the last question he wrote the date of the next management meeting. Filling in the table was only the beginning.


Epilogue

The professor presented a real case from a project EXA carried out at a large company in 2008. The company had never calculated or reviewed throughput. Its attention had been elsewhere. In the decision-making system EXA built at the time, throughput was EXA's recommendation for the first item to report, for the reasons set out in this story. Those same reasons explain why the story identifies the throughput trend as the first figure to watch. The story arranges the figures from that case into six quarters.

Does your company track the trend in sales revenue less directly variable costs such as material costs alongside operating expense? What decisions does that figure lead to in management meetings?

Next Episode

Does the company generate cash fast enough? In the next class, the students measure Cash Tied-up Days, identify the assets that tie up cash, and examine how much working capital the company can recover by speeding up the cycle while keeping the business running. Along the way they ask how an increase in cash differs from an increase in accounting profit.

Loading comments

Join the discussion

…